I was a little disappointed in this episode, not because I didn’t like it but because it was just a smidge beneath the bar set by the previous few episodes. If this were an episode of almost any other show on television, I’d have considered it spectacular output, but since it’s The Americans, I feel compelled to hold it to a bit of a higher standard. I think much of what didn’t work springs from the fact that it took place during the events of an actual, well-known historical event, which is to say the attempted assassination of Ronald Reagan, so we had to buy into the pivotal role the protagonists had in the events of that day. Beeman’s storyline feels real enough, but we all know so much about what happened that day that the stakes of what the Jennings are up to just don’t hit home. As long as the show doesn’t try to stage this kind of big historical event too often (and, really, Reagan was only shot at once so presumably that’s all we’ll get too) I don’t think it hurts its overall strength much.
While I’m on the subject of what didn’t work, I want to address one thing that has bothered me with the show so far (it’s small, so it still doesn’t affect my overarching assessment): the humor and/or dramatic irony the show tries to pull out of the kids not knowing what their parents do for a living. You can handle that kind of lack of knowledge a few different ways, but in general, most shows don’t do it very well and it’s often best left alone. So when we see Paige talking to Matthew (Agent Beeman’s son) about his father’s job as an agent for the FBI, and how she’s glad her parents work a safe job like ‘travel agent-ing,” it doesn’t land at all. To make matters worse, the two teens then make a bunch of jokes about the inherent ‘dangers’ of being a travel agent (leaky boats, plane delays, etc). It’s such a small part of the show that I almost feel bad picking it out as a weakness, but at this point it’s happened enough that I can’t continue to ignore it – like back in episode two when Paige pointedly tells her mother that “people are freer now than when you were a kid.” No fucking kidding, and the show should consider its audience smart enough (it certainly does the rest of the time) to get that implication without having Paige say it.
What does work: we’ve watched the Jennings, over the past few episodes, evolve from the life they’ve been living – spies in reality, a married couple only as cover – to where they are now, finally beginning to consider the marriage real as well. The wordless scene we have of them meeting in a hotel room early in the episode is perfect, because it feels like the long-delayed consummation of their marriage. Yes, they’ve obviously been here before (Paige and Henry are proof), but that was part of the cover, and was for the motherland. This is for them.
Then they leave the hotel room and the honeymoon, as it were, is immediately over – they find out Reagan’s been shot. What ensues are scenes with both the FBI and the KGB, in which neither really knows what’s going on and both are trying to figure out if the other country is about to fire nuclear missiles at them. Elizabeth and Phillip are asked to begin sighting their targets, which apparently means driving around the suburbs of D.C. and literally sighting lines for sniper shots at high-ranking government officials – and they are almost caught outside the Defense Secretary’s house, so Elizabeth has to make quick work of a security guard. They then have to spend some time hiding the body, so I’m sure that will come back to haunt them in the weeks ahead.
All the while, the two of them are bickering like, well, an old married couple. It has the tone of any argument between a couple that loves each other but still has disagreements, it’s just that their disagreements happen to be about almost getting caught sighting sniper shots and how the work they’re doing represents escalation towards a possible nuclear war.
Which brings me to one more thing that’s been bugging me since the pilot: I’m not totally in love with the way Elizabeth’s character and history have been developed. This is bigger than the problems I mentioned before because it could represent a problem for the show moving forward. I know they’re trying to make her into the half of the partnership that is really loyal to the cause and truly a Russian at heart, while Phillip is represented as drawn to the American way of life and clearly willing (as is made quite obvious in the pilot) to abandon the mission, but it really feels like Elizabeth is increasingly represented as irrational where Phillip is reasonable, as rash where he is restrained. At best this speaks to the ideological slant of the show and the way the writers view Soviet-era Russians; at worst, it’s rather lazy and slightly sexist writing. They’ve tried to address Elizabeth’s motivations to act the way she does through flashbacks and some soliloquies on her part, but I’d like to see them do a better job of it in the next two-thirds of the season (also, this is only the fourth episode, so there’s ample time for character development to change dramatically).
Final notes: Nina is lucky Beeman is so damn good at his job, because she was almost made. On the other hand, Beeman is not so lucky he’s so good at his job, because it has caused (possibly) irreparable damage to his marriage.

The Weird Thing About Star Trek TNG: Realm of Fear
I’ve always been a big fan of the Star Trek series (though by no means a trekkie), and The Next Generation is my favorite incarnation of it. That being said, there’s a huge problem in the second episode of the sixth season, Realm of Fear. It’s an episode that features the bumbling Lieutenant Reginald Barclay (first seen having problems with holodeck addiction in an episode with a lot of weird masturbatory allusions, but that’s another discussion entirely) attempting to overcome his transporter-phobia. When he finally does, he ends up seeing an odd creature in the beam with him.
As science fiction, Star Trek has always been fairly conscious of the various technologies used in its version of the future. This episode, however, presents us with a major metaphysical question: how the fuck does Barclay see something while being transported? As is noted in the episode, you’re being dissembled at the molecular level and put back together at your destination. Shouldn’t this be an essentially instantaneous process, not one that leaves the traveler with time to get freaked the fuck out by gremlin-terror-worms and whatnot?
If the writers are trying to say that consciousness exists outside the body, that’s fine, but it’s not even addressed. It throws open some pretty big existential doors and subsequently ignores what’s outside them. LaForge, Riker, Troi and even freaking Picard (seriously, this is a guy who never gives up a chance to pontificate on philosophy, and he lets this one go?) don’t blink at Barclay’s apparent third eye. It would be easier to understand if this was a smaller part of the episode and a less important philosophical question, but the episode hinges on the moments Barclay is inside the transporter beam, and humans have been wondering if the mind is of the body or outside it since we’ve had the words to ask.
March 5, 2013
Categories: episode commentary . Tags: commentary, reviews, star trek, television . Author: David . Comments: 2 Comments